‘Much Ado About Nothing’ Review: Nothing Indeed

Published: Nov 21, 2026 12:41 PM

Most significantly — and most cripplingly — why should anyone care whether Hero is a virgin? The “nothing” in Much Ado’s title is a three-way pun: It refers to the chaos that’s caused when Don John manages to convince Claudio that his betrothed has cheated on him, to all the spying and overhearing that’s done in the play (the Elizabethan pronunciation of the word was more similar to “noting”), and to (womp womp) the female anatomy. Much Ado About Nothing doesn’t have to take place in the Italy [...] Which is why it makes sense that Shakespeare — and especially Shakespearean comedy — rejects him like a bad transplanted organ. Like plenty of big-deal men in theater, he has no real sense of humor. The Much Ado About Nothing he has directed, starring Tom Hiddleston and Hayley Atwell, arrives on Broadway like a spitwad shot out of a confetti cannon. Glitzy, cocky, glib, and loud, it lands with a sticky thud. It turns the play into a contextless, nonsensical skeleton, a kind of sad, bare [...] place in the Italy of the Medicis; it doesn’t have to be about soldiers and landed gentry; but it does have to find some solution for the weight that its plot places on feminine virtue.

Original source